Grading economics

Ten Common Card Grading Mistakes That Cost Collectors Money

Updated 3 min read

Quick answer

The costliest grading mistakes are submitting cards that were never likely to reach the needed grade, altering cards, misjudging centering, overlooking the real cost of grading, and ignoring the price gap between grades. Most are avoidable with a measured pre-grade and a clear sense of the numbers.

1. Submitting on hope

The most expensive mistake is sending a card because it "looks perfect". Cards look perfect in flat light. Graders do not use flat light. Measure and inspect before you send anything.

2. Ignoring centering

Centering is measurable and fixed. If the card is outside the tolerance for the grade you need, nothing else you do will fix it. PSA's published Gem Mint tolerance is approximately 55/45 front and 75/25 back. See the centering guide.

3. Cleaning or touching up a card

Wiping a card, pressing a bend, or rubbing an edge can lead to a no-grade for cleaning, altered stock or restoration. PSA lists those as reasons it will not assign a numeric grade, and the fee can still apply. See qualifiers and no-grade codes.

4. Judging from a flat photo

A photo taken in even light hides surface flaws. Tilt the card under one bright source. The surface guide explains how.

5. Forgetting the back

The back is graded too. Many cards have a dark-printed back that shows edge whitening and corner wear clearly. Always inspect both sides.

6. Counting only the grading fee

Shipping, insurance, supplies and selling fees all count. See grading costs and budgeting.

7. Ignoring the price gap between grades

A card where the 10 is several times the 9 needs very high odds of a 10. A card where they are close does not. See PSA 9 vs PSA 10.

8. Choosing a service level by speed alone

The right tier matches the card value and your timeline. Declared value affects both cost and acceptance.

9. Packing badly

A card that arrives damaged is graded on its arrival condition. Use rigid holders and secure packing. See how to prepare a submission.

10. Never checking the numbers

Many collectors never calculate expected value. They submit because the best-case sale price is exciting. Use the ROI formula with honest odds.

The common fix

Nine of these ten come down to the same thing: not looking closely enough before submitting. A pre-grade fixes that cheaply.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most common grading mistake?

Submitting cards on hope. People send cards that have never been measured or inspected closely, and a ceiling flaw such as off-center borders caps the grade.

Is it a mistake to clean a card first?

Yes. Cleaning can lead to a no-grade designation, and PSA states the grading fee can still apply.

How do I avoid these mistakes?

Measure and inspect before you submit, work out the economics with real prices and never alter a card.

Before you pay for grading

Put your card through the same tests, free.

Before The Grade turns the grading companies' published standards into measurable checks. Upload the front and back of a card and get a condition report that shows every measurement and every flaw it found, so you can judge the prediction yourself. 1 free report when you confirm your email.

Grading companies revise their standards and service levels. Figures here reflect what each company has published at the time of writing, so confirm details on the company's own site before you submit. Before The Grade is independent and is not affiliated with PSA, BGS, CGC or SGC.