Grading companies and scales

PSA vs BGS: Which Grading Company Should You Use?

Updated 4 min read

Quick answer

PSA gives a single overall grade from 1 to 10 and is the most commonly traded slab in the hobby. BGS gives four subgrades (centering, corners, edges, surface) plus an overall grade, which makes it easier to see why a card scored what it did. Choose by card type, by whether you plan to sell or keep, and by what buyers of that card expect.

The short answer

If you are grading to sell and you want the broadest possible pool of buyers, PSA is the default choice for most cards. If you are grading a modern card with sharp corners and clean surfaces and you want the highest-value tier a grading company offers, BGS is worth a serious look. If you are unsure, look up recent sold listings for your exact card in each company's slab and let the market decide.

The rest of this guide explains why, so you can make the call on a card-by-card basis rather than following a rule of thumb.

How each company reports a grade

The biggest structural difference is what you get back.

  • PSA assigns one overall grade on a scale from 1 to 10. You see the number and the grade name, plus a qualifier if one applies. You do not see how centering, corners, edges and surface contributed.
  • BGS (Beckett Grading Services) assigns four subgrades, one each for centering, corners, edges and surface, and then an overall grade derived from them. The overall grade is not a simple average, but the subgrades show you exactly where a card was strong or weak.

That difference matters before you submit. With BGS-style thinking you ask which of the four areas is the weakest, because that area drags the result. With PSA-style thinking you ask whether any single flaw is bad enough to drop the card a full tier.

Centering

PSA publishes its Gem Mint 10 centering tolerance as approximately 55/45 on the front and 75/25 on the reverse. That is one of the few hard numbers in any grading company's standards, and it is why centering is the first thing worth measuring on a card you hope will reach the top grade.

BGS scores centering as its own subgrade, which means a card with excellent corners, edges and surface cannot hide mediocre centering, and a card with strong centering gets credit for it even if another area is weaker. Check Beckett's current published scale for its exact thresholds, because companies update their standards.

Resale and liquidity

Grading is a means to an end, and for most people the end is a sale. PSA slabs are generally the most commonly listed and traded graded cards, which tends to mean more buyers recognize the label and trust it without further research. That familiarity is a real advantage if you value a quick, easy sale.

BGS has a loyal following, particularly among modern collectors, and its top tiers can command strong prices for the right cards. The practical way to check is to compare sold listings for your card in both slabs at the same grade tier. Do not assume; look.

The top-grade question

Both companies have a top tier that is notably harder to reach than the tier just below it.

QuestionPSABGS
What does the top grade look like?A single PSA 10A BGS 9.5 (Gem Mint) or a BGS 10 (Pristine)
What is the rarest designation?PSA 10BGS 10 with all four subgrades at 10 (Black Label)
Can I see why a card missed?Not directlyYes, through the subgrades
Where does a miss usually come from?One flaw dropping the overall gradeOne weak subgrade pulling the overall grade down

Because a miss on the top tier can be expensive in terms of expected value, it helps to know in advance how close a card sits to the line. That is the problem pre-grading solves.

Which cards suit which company

These are tendencies, not rules.

  • Modern cards with clean, sharp printing (recent Pokemon sets, modern sports) can do well at BGS if all four areas are strong, because the subgrades reward consistency.
  • Cards you expect to sell quickly often suit PSA because of the size of the buyer pool.
  • Cards with one standout strength and one weakness, such as perfect surface but slightly soft corners, are easier to reason about with BGS subgrades because you can see the trade-off.
  • Vintage cards are graded by several companies, and PSA has a long history with vintage. See vintage vs modern card grading.

A simple decision framework

  1. Pull up recent sold listings for your exact card in a PSA slab and a BGS slab.
  2. Note the price at the grade you realistically expect, not the grade you hope for.
  3. Compare grading fees and turnaround for the service level you would need, using each company's current price list.
  4. Pre-grade the card to estimate which tier it is likely to land in.
  5. Pick the company where expected value, not best-case value, is higher.

Step four is where most people guess. A step-by-step pre-grade takes minutes and replaces a guess with measurements.

Frequently asked questions

Is PSA or BGS better?

Neither is better in every case. PSA slabs are the most widely traded, which helps resale. BGS reports four subgrades, which makes the grade easier to audit and gives a very high-value tier for cards that earn top marks. The better choice depends on the card and your plan for it.

Does BGS grade harder than PSA?

They weigh condition differently rather than one being simply harder. BGS scores each of centering, corners, edges and surface, so a single weak area is visible in the report. PSA assigns one overall grade, so the same flaw is absorbed into one number.

Which company should I use for Pokemon cards?

Both grade Pokemon cards, and the answer depends on the card and what buyers of that specific card prefer. Look at recent sold listings for your exact card in each company slab and see which sells more easily.

Before you pay for grading

Put your card through the same tests, free.

Before The Grade turns the grading companies' published standards into measurable checks. Upload the front and back of a card and get a condition report that shows every measurement and every flaw it found, so you can judge the prediction yourself. 1 free report when you confirm your email.

Grading companies revise their standards and service levels. Figures here reflect what each company has published at the time of writing, so confirm details on the company's own site before you submit. Before The Grade is independent and is not affiliated with PSA, BGS, CGC or SGC.